Re: Bad idea: Punishing false rape accusers

Rauni wrote:
>"Sir Jessy of Anti" wrote:

>>So it's reasonable for her to hypothetically punch him in the face, but not
>>*fair* for him

>Damn are you trying to be stupid?  I don't recall saying that her
>behavior were reasonable. Actually it is stupid. But to defend himself
>from what? All he has to do is leave and never be around the bitch
>again. He would have to be in immediate physical threat for it to
>reasonable for him to return a punch.

>>to defend himself by doing likewise?   Seems you are the one who
>>misunderstands the definition

>I suggest you look up the definition of defense. He is not defending
>himself. He will end in jail if he punches back. Same would apply if
>he were in a bar and a stranger punched him and he punched back thus
>causing bodily harm to the stranger

Wrong.

miguel