Re: [****] Why didn't the Palestinian Arabs Accept Partition?

On Tue, 02 Dec 2003 16:12:45 -0800 James A. Donald <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:

:>James A. Donald
:>> :> > :> For the past sixty years or so, almost every day,
:>> :> > :> some arabs have been thrown out of their farms and/or
:>> :> > :> houses by what is supposedly a very small faction of
:>> :> > :> Jews, who somehow invariably wind up being backed by
:>> :> > :> the entire Jewish army.   Hebron is a good example of
:>> :> > :> this.  Some Jews come into town, and seize a hotel. 
:>> :> > :> Theoretically this is a tiny extremist radical Jewish
:>> :> > :> faction.  Hotel owners attempt to throw them out.
:>> :> > :> Pretty soon the Israeli army has the entire town
:>> :> > :> under lockdown, arabs are being shot on sight if they
:>> :> > :> wander into certain parts of town or attempt to get
:>> :> > :> out of their houses at certain times, and ever
:>> :> > :> increasing chunks of the town are being bulldozed.

:>Binyamin Dissen
:>> :> > Ah, the typical uneducated neo-nazi revisionist.

:>> :> > Denies that Jews were living in Hebron for thousands of 
:>> :> > years, until 1929, when the Mufti, the ally of his hero 
:>> :> > Hitler, performed genocide on the Jews living there.

:>James A. Donald:
:>> > The arabs who did that bad stuff long ago are all dead.

:>Binyamin Dissen
:>> So what is your objection to Jews returning to Hebron?

:>No objection, if they paid the guy who built the hotel, which
:>they did not,  if the hotel was built on land originally stolen
:>from jews, which it was not, (Hebron has been a predominantly
:>arab city since the crusades) and if they got a title to the
:>land under the buildings they seized from the rightful heirs of
:>those who had been wrongfully dispossessed, which they did not.

It was Jewish before then.

Why do you eagerly and gladly accept the dispossession of the Jews, yet get
all whiny when the Jews recover their stolen land?

What is it about you KKKlansmen and whining?

:>Instead what is happening is a rolling dispossession, in which
:>one building after another gets demolished, the entire arab
:>population of Hebron is under extreme and steadily growing
:>pressure to move out, and the times and places where arabs are
:>apt to be shot on sight steadily expands.

Yet you had no problem at all with the Jews being genocided.

How typical of your ilk.

:>> Did the cowardly arab moslems that committed the genocide, a
:>> fact which I forced you to concede, gain possession of the
:>> land?

:>Hebron has been a majority arab city since the crusades.

Why start the clock at the crusades?

:>                                                          The
:>Jews are taking it all.  Every single arab in Hebron is under
:>extreme and growing pressure to move out.   At the time of the
:>massacre, there were 800 jews, and tens of thousands of arabs,
:>so only a rather small patch of the city was Jewish, and the
:>patch where the current seizure started was a long way from
:>that patch, and done against people who had no connection with
:>those crimes.  Sixty seven jews were murdered, in order to
:>dispossess them all.   Only the heirs of those dispossessed
:>have the right to seek compensation.

False.

:>Your reasoning is like that of Bin Laden.  Because the
:>Spaniards committed crimes against the Muslims a thousand years
:>ago in what is now Spain, he is entitled to blow up Americans.

Snicker.

:>> :> If you are entitled to punish today's arabs for the
:>> :> misdeeds of their grandparents, then surely Jews should be
:>> :> punished for all that bad stuff they did over the past
:>> :> several thousand years.

:>> What did the Jews do?

:>Stole Canaan, massacred the population of Tyre, etc, etc.  If
:>you are going to punish the sons for the sins of their fathers,
:>you have grounds to kill and rob anyone. 

Provide proof for your assertions.

Then they can be addressed.

--
Binyamin Dissen <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
http://www.dissensoftware.com