Re: Way to go, Dutch - you just made Fuckwit's argument for him.

On Tue, 2 Dec 2003 11:33:45 -0800, "Dutch" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:

>"ipse dixit" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote
>> On Tue, 2 Dec 2003 09:42:53 -0800, "Dutch" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote
>> >"ipse dixit" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote
>> >[..]
>> >
>> >> Now THAT could be true if you look at it the
>> >> right way. I'm not Jon, and "firstoftwins" can
>> >> vouch for that, but I could never guarantee you
>> >> I'm not "just another character the Gonad
>> >> is *playing.*",
>> >
>> >No, you're a sock-puppet of Derek Nash.
>> >
>> Evidence please!
>
>Are you denying it?
>
Answering either way will obviously weaken my 
anonymity to some degree, so I refuse to answer 
on that basis. Now let's have your evidence to this 
unsupported claim you've just made.

>> >> >    Dutch doesn't think it is a benefit afaik.
>> >>
>> >> Yes, he does,
>> >
>> >No, I do not.
>> >
>> I've proved that you do by showing what you
>> have conceded to.
>
>Nope.
>
>> >> and these comments (below)  prove it.
>> >
>> >No they do not..
>> >
>> Which is why you snipped them away. Yeah right.
>
>I flush shit down the loo also.
>
You've been flushing EVERTHING down the loo.
there isn't a single discussion you haven't snipped
and run from all week, nebbish.

>> >> He believes an animal benefits
>> >> from getting to experience life and being
>> >> able to reproduce after their predators have
>> >> been removed by our moral consideration
>> >> toward them.
>> >
>> >Deer populations benefit from removal of predators, just as human
>> >populations benefit from removal of murderers.
>> >
<unsnip>

That's not all you've said or admitted to. You
have conceded, this very day in another thread 
to this, that animals benefit from getting to 
experience life AND from being able to 
reproduce.
Check this beauty out;
[start ipse dixit]
>> The quotes and admissions below prove you
>> believe an animal benefits from getting to
>> experience life and being able to reproduce after
>> their predators have been removed
>
>Of course they do. 

Way to go ...!!!!!!!!
<end>