Re: Docs serve up diet surprise: Fat may help, soy may not stop cancer

"Diarmid Logan" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> ha scritto nel messaggio
news:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> http://theedge.bostonherald.com/healthNews/edgeHealth.bg?articleid=75
>
> Docs serve up diet surprise: Fat may help, soy may not stop cancer
>
> By Michael Lasalandra
>
> Tuesday, October 28, 2003
>
> Studies presented yesterday on the link between diet and cancer
> offered some unconventional ideas, suggesting high-fat diets may help
> prevent prostate cancer progression and diets high in soy neither
> increase nor reduce the risk of breast cancer.
>
> "A diet with fewer carbohydrates may be more effective in preventing
> progression to advanced, lethal prostate cancer than a diet with low
> fat content," said Dr. Ada Elgavish of the University of Alabama.
>
> Her study in mice

Studies on mice and rats diet are useless for human health !!
Mice don't belong to the same classes of humans, they're not primate
They're adapted by nature by a diet low in carbohydrates, they don't eat
fruits
Rats and mice have nothing to do with humans with respect to trophic
features
They belong to a difference class compared to primate humans
They are not adapted to an high carb diets of fruits, berries, vegetables,
nut and fish
In fact, while humans handle fructose quite well, fructose is quite
dangerous to mice, but we know that primates eat fruits whereas I have never
seen rats eating a banana

As Steve Harris says "If you're a rat,
you shouldn't eat fructose.  Next rat that comes to me for a health
consultation, I'll be sure and council him very well on the issue"

So please, don't even post studies on rats or mice that are supposed to be
used for human health, they're cruelty useless and if one is going to change
his/her diet because of rats experiments then they become even dangerous !!

I would dismiss Dr. Ada Elgavish from University just for being so idiot and
ignorant as to
squander her time and the nation money for such stupid studies, whilst she
had just to consult a
comparative anatomy professor to know that her stupid study was going to
give results that doesnt' apply to humans

Nicholas
























found those that ate diets high in fat and low in
> carbohydrates had significantly lower rates of advanced prostate
> cancer and sharply higher survival rates than those fed low-fat,
> high-carbohydrate diets.
>
> But experts at the American Association for Cancer Research conference
> in Phoenix cautioned against anyone changing their diets based on the
> results of a small study in mice.
>
> A few studies in men with early stage prostate cancer have shown a
> low-fat diet can stall the disease's progression and even reverse it.
>
> A second study presented yesterday suggested diets high in fruits and
> vegetables can significantly lower breast cancer risk, but found high
> soy intake had no association, either positive or negative.
>
> The study on 378 women was conducted in China and was led by
> researchers at Oregon Health and Science University.
>
> Women who consumed at least four servings of fruits and vegetables per
> day had a 50 percent lower risk, and those who ate the most fruit
> lowered their risk by 70 percent, said Jackelin Shannon, lead author.
>
> But the lack of an association with high soy intake was the most
> intriguing finding, she said.
>
> Dr. John Potter of the Fred Hutchinson Cancer Research Center said the
> data on soy intake has been inconsistent. He said a study he did
> showed a reduced risk of breast cancer among those who started eating
> soy in childhood.
>
> "In general, we don't know the answer to whether soy is beneficial,"
> he said.