
www.Usenet.com
Group Index
Rec Thread Archive from Usenet.com
Unusual Penalty Enforcement in Buffalo-Houston Game
- __From__: Paige Miller
- __Subject__: Unusual Penalty Enforcement in Buffalo-Houston Game
- __Date__: Sun, 16 Nov 2003 18:57:38 -0600
Buffalo trails 12-8 with 0:59 left. Houston has 3rd and four. Bills out
of timeouts.
Houston running back Davis runs for 3 yards, but there's a holding
penalty against Houston. You would expect Buffalo to decline the
penalty, resulting in 4th and about 1, Houston punts, and Buffalo gets
the ball back. That's what you would expect.
Referee Johnny Grier announces that Buffalo accepts the penalty and his
umpire moves the ball back 10 yeards, despite, on camera, visually, and
through Grier's own microphone, verbally, Buffalo defensive captain
London Fletcher is clearly declining the penalty. Clearly and
vociferously. (After that, with another third down play, the clocks runs
down to 0:03 before fourth down snap, and then Houston, instead of
punting, runs out the clock. Had Buffalo declined, Houston punts with
about 0:52 on the clock...)
A later radio broadcast attributes this information to Buffalo Coach
Gregg Williams, whom we know is somewhat unreliable in his ability to
communicate clearly on matters of rules and refereeing. Nevertheless,
let's for the moment accept Williams' statement as factual. Williams
says Grier told him that another Buffalo player had accepted the
penalty. No identification of this player was made, according to the
radio announcer repeating what Williams had said.
Can a player other than the captain accept a penalty?
If one player (not the defensive captain) accepts the penalty, and then
if subsequently the defensive captain declines the penalty, what SHOULD
the ref do?
Or do you suspect, as I do, that the story missing some information
somewhere?
--
Paige Miller
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://home.rochester.rr.com/djpaige/blogger.html
It's nothing until I call it -- Bill Klem, NL Umpire
If you get the choice to sit it out or dance,
I hope you dance -- Lee Ann Womack
- Unusual Penalty Enforcement in Buffalo-Houston Game,
Paige Miller