Re: I CAN'T HEAR YOU????

On Mon, 1 Dec 2003 23:06:00 -0600, "\"MIDIcian\" \(tm\)"
<[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:

><[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote in message
>news:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
>>   I hope you don't turn out to be one of the hate mongers posting
>> under another name. Reading your post, this doesn't appear to be the
>> case. Your point will be missed by Mr Rosenthal and he will likely
>> call you names.
>
>No, I'm just not gonna respond to his silly post.  We aren't in a
>hypothetical situation here - it is real.

  Yet you replied in other messages to most of his post anyhow. I
haven't seen another post from him so he was either a one time poster
that suddenly decided to speak or the hate mongers may be getting a
bit more eloquent with thier wording. The "hypothetical" situation
could easily be real. This is pretty much what is going on.

>> Please don't be offended, this is the norm.
>
>Straw man.

  You seem to have a thing with this, something we should know? It
appears to me that you may wish to look in a mirror before calling
anyone a "straw man". You have stuck the the same rhetoric statements
with little or no defense for those statements and when someone has
asked you questions outside the scope of those statements you have
dodged them.

>>   Unfortunately, people like him are not worried about the US
>> withhholding it's support. If that were to happen, Israel would have
>> no choice but to make peace. Until the day that happens, they will
>> continue to preach their message of hatred towards the palestinians in
>> the name of self defense.
>
>If the US withheld it's support, Israel would be forced to wipe out all the
>Palestinians in (what is called) Palestine (these days) and retake Israels
>land.
>
>
>Stan

  That would be the end of Israel and you know it. Without the support
of the US, Israel would be unable to wipe out the palestinians and
then defend themselves against the rest of the Arab world (and others
I'm sure).

  I do not agree with his idea of turning Israel loose to fend for
itself, that would be condemning the Israeli people to death. The
government should be held accountable for the human rights violations
and everything else it's guilty of condoning.

  I see you're falling back on outdated cliche's, "All's fair in love
and war"..... Aren't you glad the US and Britain didn't feel that way
during WW2? Hell, if that was the attitude then, no one might have
cared what Hitler did with the Jews...