Re: Query - Punjabi Song / Mitti Deya Bhandiya Akheer Bhajnda / If it exists

I just remembered another song, which pre-dates all three songs
(Punjabi - Non-Film,  Bombai Ka Chor  and Sankalp)  and has 
similar theme (you can call it the eldest-sister,  since the mom is
the nazm by:   Nazir Akbarabadi.  The song is from:

         NAACH (1949) / Husnlal Bhagatram 

                 Kyon Karta Maan Jawani Ka x 2
                 Tu Ek Bulbla Pani Ka

                            by:  Geeta Roy ,  Lata & Rafi


very nice lyrics  by:  Mulkraj Bhakri and quite good composition.
The song has not been re-issed by HMV.

for  Data-Collectors.        It is one of the few songs, sung by
==============          Geeta, Lata & Rafi (the film has another 
                                      song by the trio,  but it is no good)



Sudhir


                                  -------------------------



 A music  enthusiast mentioned the above listed song, as a good one.
> > > > He doesn't know the artist info, so I haven't been able to buy it.
> > > > The song lyrics may be as follows:
> > > >
> > > >          Lishq Le Tu Saj Le Tu Jinaa Sajnda
> > > >          Mitti Deya Bhandiya Aakhir Bhajnda
> > > >
> > > > (The lyrics reminds me of similar theme song from the film:  SANKALP /
> > > >   Sab Thaath Pada Rah Jayega, Jab Laad Chalega Banjara)
> > > >
> > > >
> > > > Sudhir
> > >
> > >
> > >
> > >          Re : "Sankalp" song.
> > >
> > >          The original is in fact a well-known longish poem by
> > >          the noted Urdu poet Nazir Akbarabadi, where he has
> > >          highlighted the transient nature of this worldly life.
> > >
> > >
> > >          Afzal