Re: Mustaq Gadar's PAKISTANI CINEMA (1947-97)

[EMAIL PROTECTED] (Rirfan6) wrote in message news:<[EMAIL PROTECTED]>...
> >!Even MG in his book is
> >> WRONG.
> 
>  Although MG book contains many errors,
>  but about this particular information, he is
>  RIGHT. How is it......!
>  Fortunately Allah has distributed  knowledge among His creations so that
>  it may be acquired by those who strive
>  for this honestly, without wearing any
>  glasses.
>  Rafi did sang one song in this film -
>  mein uss sey karooN pyar
>  vo mujh sey karey pyar
>  I have already narrated how and why KA
>  left the film - Yateem. After his exit this
>  song was recorded in GMD's voice for
>  GP record by either Gadeker(KA's assiss-
>  tant) or by K.Datta.
>  Rafi's version is available in the film only
>  if someone can get hold the print.
> 
>  A quiz for JAY.
>  C.Ramchandra was a great fan of KA. 
>  According to his own account he used to
>  listen to KA's reharsals by standing at
>  the window of  the reharsal room( this was
>  narrated by Tanvir Naqvi, who had a long
>  association with CR, in his article -
>  Filmi Sha'iree - published in weekly
>  Lail-o-Nahaar edited by Faiz in1962).
>  CR was insired by this song and  composed a song in late 50's.
>  Can JAY kindly solve this quiz?
> 
>  Warm regards,
> 
>  Irfan
> 
>  P.S (HINT) The mukh.Da has somewhat
>  the same words in different setting.

I feel INPUT DATA is not enough to spot out the mysterious number.

If CR used to listen 'chupke chupke' to listen to KA's takes during
the late '50s as you mention (KA had migrated to Pak around '53,to be
noted),the ONLY POSSIBLE film songs could have been from
either,SINGAAR or NISHANA or
NEELAM PARI.Unfortunately,I can't find any of KA's compositions
imbibed  by CR to have inspired him in weaving out anything anything
'even proximate'! I could be wrong still.

Jay
2/12