
www.Usenet.com
| <-- __Chronological__ --> | <-- __Thread__ --> |
> > "The Long and Winding Road": For me this is the only one of the three that > doesn't quite work. The Spector version is an abomination, but it's clear > the Beatles just never quite nailed this one. This version sounds like a > rehearsal. Paul's vocal is a bit tentative in spots, and the instrumental > break feels not-quite-fully-worked-out. The song did need SOMETHING to make > it a finished record -- alas, Spector's version of something was hideous. > For my money the definitive arrangement of this song is the one Paul used on > the '76 Wings Over America Tour (though I do like some of the touches on the > Back in the U.S. version as well). Yeah, "Winding Road" on WOA - with the heavy bass emphasis - was probably the one version the Beatles should have strived for during the LIB sessions - maybe that's one for the next "definitive" LIB remix whenever that is.
| <-- __Chronological__ --> | <-- __Thread__ --> |