Re: (Next to no) discussion on extended version of TTT?

"Smaug69" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote ...
> "jere7my tho?rpe" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote...
> >      The person in question was Jude Fisher, who's published two books
> > (so far) of the _Fool's Gold_ trilogy, as well as the visual guides to
> > the movies.
>
> No, the person in question was Boyens since she was the only one I
> named. Try and actually read my posts next time, Sparky.

Yes, you were talking about Boyens, and this is what you said
of her:

"Smaug69" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote in message
news:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> Sorry, but some of Boyens' comments had nothing to do with filmmaking.
> She was talking about the writing style of Tolkien and how she would
> have liked to have taken a blue pencil to that Council of Elrond
> chapter. That's abhorrent, AFAIAC.

However, Boyens didn't say that,  Jude Fisher did. So you're
criticizing Boyens for a remark she never made.

-Jay